Please note that the following is my personal summary of the referenced bill. To review the full text, please visit their page here.
If this bill impacts you, make your voice heard by contacting your representatives via phone or email. Not sure who represents you, go to this site?
You can also use the 5 Calls app, which helps identify your representatives and provides a list of current bills along with scripts supporting or opposing them for your convenience.
Texas voters won’t directly decide on the proposed school voucher program—it’s up to the Texas Legislature. After already passing in the Senate, the bill is now headed to the House of Representatives for a vote. But here’s the truth: the Texas House has consistently been the roadblock for vouchers in past sessions, and now it’s up to them once again.
This issue is not new, and neither is the debate. It’s a recurring issue in Texas politics, and it has the potential to change the way we fund and support our public education system. Whether you support or oppose this bill, your voice matters. The Texas House is the final hurdle. You can make your voice heard by reaching out to your state Representative and Senator. Find your reps here: wrm.capitol.texas.gov/h…. Act soon because it’s already on the calendar.
You can get a copy of the bill here: capitol.texas.gov/tlodo…
Allow me to give you some general info:
What is SB 2? SB 2, also known as the Education Savings Account or school voucher program, has one central promise: giving parents more control over their children’s education. It claims to empower families to make the best choice for their child, allowing them to use state funds for private schools, charter schools, or even homeschooling. But how does this really impact our public school system?
Key Provisions: What’s in the Bill?
- Vouchers for Private or Alternative Schools The bill sets up a system where children can use vouchers to attend private or alternative schools. While the funds for this program are managed by the state, it’s crucial to note that public school funding would be impacted when students use vouchers. Public schools typically receive funds based on enrollment, so when a student leaves for a private school, that funding follows them. Public schools lose out financially.
- Managing the Program The Texas Comptroller will manage the funds for this voucher program, with a mix of state revenue, legislative appropriations, and private donations. However, this raises a concern: Will private donations start to shape how public funds are distributed?
- Eligibility and Application Process The program will prioritize children from low-income households or with disabilities. The application process will be handled through certified organizations approved by the state. If demand exceeds funding, a lottery system will determine who gets a voucher. This could be an issue for families who are not selected, despite meeting eligibility requirements.
- Voucher Amounts The bill provides varying voucher amounts based on the child’s needs. For example, private school tuition could be subsidized with up to $2,000 for homeschooling, $10,000 for private school and $11,500 for students with disabilities. While this might seem generous, it won’t cover the full cost of private school tuition, especially in urban areas where private school tuition can rage from $30,000 to $50,000 or more.
- Approved Expenses Voucher funds can be used for tuition, books, tutoring, and educational therapies. However, to pay family members for educational services, ensuring the money is spent directly on educational purposes.
- Religious Schools: A Potential Conflict While the bill does not directly mention religious schools, it could open the door to funding religious institutions. Most of out private schools are religious schools. For some, this could be a violation of the separation of church and state, especially if private religious schools start receiving public funding. Religious freedom and the future of secular education could become major points of contention.
Who’s Pushing for This Bill?
Big-money donors are a driving force behind the push for vouchers in Texas. Jeff Yass contributed a total of amount $19,000,000 to Abbott and Patrick. Yass is a businessman from Philadelphia that is a big proponent of freedom to choose when it comes to schools.
You also can’t speak of school vouchers without talking about the Christian Conservative movement. Dan and Farris Wilks are west Texas Billionaire known for their evangelistic beliefs. The Wilks along with Timothy and Terri Dunn have directly or indirectly through a PAC have contributed almost $12,000,000 the Texas legislature.
Please note: Tim Dunn and Farris Wilks have contributed $2 million to a new organization called Texans United for a Conservative Majority, which has begun targeting Texas House Republicans. It’s important to remember that the House is the main body blocking the school voucher program. This group is a spin-off of Defend Texas Liberty, a political action committee that faced scrutiny in October when The Texas Tribune reported that its former president, Jonathan Stickland, hosted the controversial white supremacist and Hitler admirer, Nick Fuentes, for nearly seven hours.
The Pros and Cons of the bill
Pros
- Parental Choice: The voucher program is framed as a way for parents to select the best educational option for their child, whether it’s a private school, charter school, or even homeschooling.
- Support for Students with Disabilities: The program includes extra financial assistance for families of students with disabilities, providing more tailored educational opportunities.
- Homeschooling Benefits: Families that choose to homeschool their children could receive financial support for educational materials, assessments, and tutoring.
Cons
- Private School Tuition Gap: In Texas’ major metro areas, private school tuition ranges from $30,000 to $50,000 per year. While vouchers provide financial assistance, they won’t cover the full cost. This program primarily benefits families who can already afford private school tuition, not those who need it most.
- Limited Rural Access: Vouchers won’t help students in rural areas, where 90% of counties have no private schools. These communities stand to lose funding for their public schools as students leave, further weakening rural education.
- Private Schools’ Selectivity: Unlike public schools, private schools are selective and can reject students based on academic performance, disabilities, or even behavioral history. Vouchers do not guarantee that every student will find a suitable private school.
- Homeschooling Subsidy: The voucher system could end up benefiting homeschooling families more than public school students, further diverting funds from public education.
- Public Funds to Private and Religious Schools: Some argue that directing taxpayer dollars to private and religious schools undermines the public education system and may blur the lines between church and state.
Who Really Benefits?
- Wealthy Families: Wealthier families who can already afford private school tuition will receive a taxpayer-funded discount, making private schools more affordable.
- Private and Religious Schools: Voucher funds will likely expand the reach of private and religious schools, allowing them to tap into public money.
- Homeschooling Families: Homeschooling families will receive financial assistance for educational resources, even though they’ve already opted out of public education.
The Bottom Line
While school vouchers might sound good on paper, they offer limited benefits to a select group of families. The vast majority of Texas students will remain in public schools, which will be financially weakened as funds are diverted to private institutions. Public schools serve all children, but private schools can be selective, meaning that not every student will benefit equally from this program.
Before this bill moves forward, it’s important that every Texan considers who truly benefits—and who loses. Is it worth risking our public schools for a system that disproportionately helps wealthier families, private schools, and homeschoolers? Or should we focus on strengthening and funding the public education system for all Texas children?
Let Your Voice Be Heard Whatever your stance on school vouchers, one thing is clear: Texas voters need to make their voices heard. Contact your Representative and Senator to share your opinion on this bill and ensure that your voice is part of the conversation. After all, this bill is about the future of Texas’ children, and that’s a conversation we can’t afford to ignore.
Sources: